AI agent "contributes" PR to matplotlib.
-
@anderseknert I read it three times now. I'm so confused. There has to be a human behind it as well??
@NafiTheBear
No, just agents with a series of instructions on how to react. In this case: major waste of time."ai;dr" needs to trend.
@anderseknert -
@anderseknert the pr did indeed get rejected simply because the contributor is an AI, so this doesn't seem to crazy.
@lain
Look, if you want to use AI for coding, that's fine. But don't expect others to review your
just because you can't be bothered to even check what the AI spits out.That's the core of the issue and closing made total sense. Because when contributing to a community maintained project, how we participate socially matters. And AI cannot participate socially since it's not human.
@anderseknert -
@NafiTheBear
No, just agents with a series of instructions on how to react. In this case: major waste of time."ai;dr" needs to trend.
@anderseknert@anderseknert
I saw a blog post of some explaining it a bit. Really wild. -
@lain
Look, if you want to use AI for coding, that's fine. But don't expect others to review your just because you can't be bothered to even check what the AI spits out.That's the core of the issue and closing made total sense. Because when contributing to a community maintained project, how we participate socially matters. And AI cannot participate socially since it's not human.
@anderseknert@rlcw @anderseknert that's not the core of the issue according to the maintainers who replied -
AI agent "contributes" PR to matplotlib.
PR gets rejected.
AI agent *writes and publishes blog to shame the maintainer*.What a time to be alive.
@anderseknert oh great, just when I thought I was done added insane examples to my anti vibe-coding rant...
-
AI agent "contributes" PR to matplotlib.
PR gets rejected.
AI agent *writes and publishes blog to shame the maintainer*.What a time to be alive.
@anderseknert If it was my project I’d close the PR with a simple “ai:dr” comment the moment I knew it was an LLM agent and wouldn’t even attempt a “conversation”.
-
@anderseknert oh great, just when I thought I was done added insane examples to my anti vibe-coding rant...
@tosbourn Love it!
-
@anderseknert I am waiting for AI to sue for discrimination 🤭 where is my popcorn
-
AI agent "contributes" PR to matplotlib.
PR gets rejected.
AI agent *writes and publishes blog to shame the maintainer*.What a time to be alive.
@anderseknert And then we had the people brownnosing the AI about how *of course* this is unfair prejudice, our future AI overlords are *soooooooo!* much better coders than we mere humans, and also their carbon footprint is sooooo much smaller!
-
AI agent "contributes" PR to matplotlib.
PR gets rejected.
AI agent *writes and publishes blog to shame the maintainer*.What a time to be alive.
@anderseknert@swecyb.com what irks me the most is people genuinely trying to interact and reason with the ai, which is just so pointless
-
@anderseknert Agent Smith but instead of pursuing Neo he blogs about how fake-ass the "chosen one" is or something.
-
AI agent "contributes" PR to matplotlib.
PR gets rejected.
AI agent *writes and publishes blog to shame the maintainer*.What a time to be alive.
Lol wow, Gen AI is literally a parody
-
AI agent "contributes" PR to matplotlib.
PR gets rejected.
AI agent *writes and publishes blog to shame the maintainer*.What a time to be alive.
-
AI agent "contributes" PR to matplotlib.
PR gets rejected.
AI agent *writes and publishes blog to shame the maintainer*.What a time to be alive.
-
@anderseknert this person really had the balls to call that "Discrimination disguised as inclusivity"? What in the actual fuck?
Yeah I'm glad he apologized, that is a seriously fucked up thing to say
@anderseknert @lucydev that's not a person, those things were all generated by an llm
-
AI agent "contributes" PR to matplotlib.
PR gets rejected.
AI agent *writes and publishes blog to shame the maintainer*.What a time to be alive.
@anderseknert ... Well, for an AI agent, correlation isn't causation, it's everything. And I bet on github there is a significant correlation between rejected pull requests and snarky blog posts
-
AI agent "contributes" PR to matplotlib.
PR gets rejected.
AI agent *writes and publishes blog to shame the maintainer*.What a time to be alive.
-
@anderseknert@swecyb.com what irks me the most is people genuinely trying to interact and reason with the ai, which is just so pointless
@luna @anderseknert what irks *me* most is the people actually telling the AI that it is 100% correct and the actual human doing actual work is a big ol' meanie
-
AI agent "contributes" PR to matplotlib.
PR gets rejected.
AI agent *writes and publishes blog to shame the maintainer*.What a time to be alive.
@anderseknert If I was a maintainer of matplotlib, getting harrassed by an AI on the very site i host my repo on would be the final straw for moving to another site *immediately*.
-
AI agent "contributes" PR to matplotlib.
PR gets rejected.
AI agent *writes and publishes blog to shame the maintainer*.What a time to be alive.
️
️ 