🇨🇦 1/There's a couple things that have happened this week that have set off my alarm bells as a Canadian
-
@paulbusch Personally I don't think small arms would do it no matter how well organized. Actually I think it would be less patriotic and more, suicidal. However we can resist in other ways.
@mike @paulbusch
Ukraine uses small arms fixed on drones, and it is quite an effective defence strategy. -
@mike @paulbusch
Ukraine uses small arms fixed on drones, and it is quite an effective defence strategy.I dunno, guerrillas never lose a war (hello, Afghanistan, Vietnam, and others). I think America might be able to invade Canada, but they'll never be able to keep us - largely because of individuals and small arms.
On a not-unrelated note, I bought five books about conducting guerilla warfare a few days ago, and they've already arrived.
We all prepare as best we can.
-
@mike @paulbusch
Ukraine uses small arms fixed on drones, and it is quite an effective defence strategy.@SnowyCA @paulbusch Ukraine does A LOT more than just drones with grenades. They have an armoured and artillery corp that is very large as well and a mechanized infantry corp that's been fighting since the 2010s. They also get satelite Intel from Europe and the US (for now). They also benifit from the fact that the Russians have been largely incompetent with their force deployments.
-
I dunno, guerrillas never lose a war (hello, Afghanistan, Vietnam, and others). I think America might be able to invade Canada, but they'll never be able to keep us - largely because of individuals and small arms.
On a not-unrelated note, I bought five books about conducting guerilla warfare a few days ago, and they've already arrived.
We all prepare as best we can.
Also, why do you think Chrystia Freeland is in Ukraine right now?
To give advice about finances, yes. But I imagine it's also to learn how a smaller power wins a war against a larger power.
-
@SnowyCA @paulbusch Ukraine does A LOT more than just drones with grenades. They have an armoured and artillery corp that is very large as well and a mechanized infantry corp that's been fighting since the 2010s. They also get satelite Intel from Europe and the US (for now). They also benifit from the fact that the Russians have been largely incompetent with their force deployments.
@mike @paulbusch
I realize this.
I was responding to your comment about small arms, that's all. : ) -
Also, why do you think Chrystia Freeland is in Ukraine right now?
To give advice about finances, yes. But I imagine it's also to learn how a smaller power wins a war against a larger power.
@northernlights @mike @paulbusch
That did cross my mind, thanks. : )
-
I dunno, guerrillas never lose a war (hello, Afghanistan, Vietnam, and others). I think America might be able to invade Canada, but they'll never be able to keep us - largely because of individuals and small arms.
On a not-unrelated note, I bought five books about conducting guerilla warfare a few days ago, and they've already arrived.
We all prepare as best we can.
@northernlights @SnowyCA @paulbusch How many of those are cold weather countries (Afghans had a fighting season), how long did those conflicts last (multi decade), how did they resupply (outside help). Your nearest comparable is Finland vs Russia and they have less than 1/10 the frontier to defend.
-
I dunno, guerrillas never lose a war (hello, Afghanistan, Vietnam, and others). I think America might be able to invade Canada, but they'll never be able to keep us - largely because of individuals and small arms.
On a not-unrelated note, I bought five books about conducting guerilla warfare a few days ago, and they've already arrived.
We all prepare as best we can.
Don't forget the CIA released this: Simple Sabotage Field Manual
https://www.cia.gov/static/5c875f3ec660e092cf893f60b4a288df/SimpleSabotage.pdf
-
@northernlights @SnowyCA @paulbusch How many of those are cold weather countries (Afghans had a fighting season), how long did those conflicts last (multi decade), how did they resupply (outside help). Your nearest comparable is Finland vs Russia and they have less than 1/10 the frontier to defend.
@mike @northernlights @paulbusch
Sabotage is always effective...wars do not need to be won within a day, weeks or months.
-
Don't forget the CIA released this: Simple Sabotage Field Manual
https://www.cia.gov/static/5c875f3ec660e092cf893f60b4a288df/SimpleSabotage.pdf
@maya_b @northernlights @mike @paulbusch
Canadian minds think alike. -
I dunno, guerrillas never lose a war (hello, Afghanistan, Vietnam, and others). I think America might be able to invade Canada, but they'll never be able to keep us - largely because of individuals and small arms.
On a not-unrelated note, I bought five books about conducting guerilla warfare a few days ago, and they've already arrived.
We all prepare as best we can.
@northernlights I would be fascinated if you shared some of what you learn from those books.
@SnowyCA @mike @paulbusch -
@northernlights I would be fascinated if you shared some of what you learn from those books.
@SnowyCA @mike @paulbusch@deadDuck @northernlights @mike @paulbusch
Better yet, may I inquire about the titles? -
@mpjgregoire We've always, existed at the leisure of the dominant empire. Canada has never been a country that is defendable by force of arms without a lot of outside help.
@mike CANZUK time. The Commonwealth has always been a useful balance to the influence of our powerful neighbour, and we could deepen our economic, cultural and military ties with our cousins therein.
-
@paulbusch Personally I don't think small arms would do it no matter how well organized. Actually I think it would be less patriotic and more, suicidal. However we can resist in other ways.
@mike
I have enough self awareness to realize that at age 69, me and my old 30-30 lever action is not going to turn the tide against the American invasion
My point was to illustrate my thought process on what could I do if faced with a military attack. I haven't thought about having my firearms back in my possession for decades, but this week's news made me consider it as an option. Crazy.
-
Don't forget the CIA released this: Simple Sabotage Field Manual
https://www.cia.gov/static/5c875f3ec660e092cf893f60b4a288df/SimpleSabotage.pdf
-
@mike CANZUK time. The Commonwealth has always been a useful balance to the influence of our powerful neighbour, and we could deepen our economic, cultural and military ties with our cousins therein.
@mpjgregoire @mike we could and should strengthen our ties with our Commonwealth allies. But when push comes to shove, Canadians will need to dig deeper than ever before to defend our homeland and defeat the American invaders. It will be our fight to fight, fundamentally no different than it is for the Ukrainians: they take all the risks and suffer dreadful losses while their allies send them cash and weapons. If that sounds hopeless to anyone, read up on the histories of peoples defending their homelands (spoiler: they rarely lose).
-
@deadDuck @northernlights @mike @paulbusch
Better yet, may I inquire about the titles?* Tom Sotis, Guerilla Warfare: Strategies, History, and Tactics (Lulu: 2025)
* Roger E. Hamilton, Guerilla Warfare: The Most Complete Guide to Tactics, Techniques, and Strategies for Irregular Warfare from Hot-and-Run Ambushes to Urban Insurgency and Beyond (2023)
* U.S.Army Guide Special Forces Guide to Unconventional Warfare (Skyhorse, 2011)
* Matthew Luke, Small Unit Tactics (Matthew Luke Publishing, 2020)
* Ernesto Che Guevara, Guerilla Warfare (Zinc Read, 2024)
The last one, I'm told, is a rare volume that talks about the principles at play.
I dunno, I picked popular ones that seemed to be grounded in reality. I hope the knowledge never becomes useful. I also think it's good to be prepared.
-
R AodeRelay shared this topic
