I have a friend being evaluated for pancreatic cancer.
-
@andycarolan @feld @brianvastag >> Those are amazing pictures! Looks gorgeous! I wasn’t aware what coral bleaching was, so just did a search. Another effect of climate change I see. Ugh
Why is this not bigger news?!
Well you know the bleaching news is getting less and less these days. After 2023 there’s not much left to bleach. Below is a porite coral that mustard hill. It’s one of the strongest corals out there for heat and water quality toasted in 2023. More terrifying is the upside down jellyfish in 2023 bleached in the other picture. That photos and videos I got of them was the first time wild bleaching was observed. The species that we studied for their zooz to try to solve the problem. They bleach at far higher temperatures so it was once thought we could use them. To transplant their zooz to the coral and give them more time. Well the wild bleaching of this species shows that even they are not immune. That the frontier hope of restoring coral was just obliterated by the effects outrunning the species.
These things are very real and happening. Coral, anemones, flatworms, Halimeda, sponges, jellyfish all bleached. Moon jellies turned black. Never in my life had I seen that scale of damage. 2023 was really the fork in the road.
So with bigger news? Well there’s not really any news since it went from 80% coral cover in 1995 to 0.5% in 2023 though many warm and cold bleaching events. what are you really going to show? It’s already happened. With really minimal observation by science. We should have had weekly if not bi weekly data for every single reef if we took it seriously and be able to look that up and see what’s happened.
So not really much to show there. That’s where we are at. It’s not like I’m trying to be scary either it’s just what it is. I’m not unaware either of what economic damage would result from deciding to fix this. What we would have to do as a species. That’s a non starter to put the globe in an instant depression to resolve it is not viable. That resolves nothing as we would lose the ability to make it work. So not like I’m saying we need to do immediate policy change. That won’t help anything to force massive change to resolve it.
It just is what it is, not that I’ve given up by any means. Just physics and chemistry doesn’t care about what we feel. Just the same as it doesn’t care if I do decompression properly it will gladly let me do it. It will let me damage my body, paralyze myself or kill myself. With zero complaints. Physics does not care of what we want. We are subject to its rules and its consequences. With that, I haven’t given up but I’ve just accepted what the laws of the universe dictate will happen. Gas saturation laws, thermodynamics, chemistry with gas interacting. Those are invisible forces that we cannot escape.
It’s gonna be rough in the future, post 2034 is my cutoff date when it really starts to become noticeable. In few short years we will see it switch. That’s when we will take real action. But what will we have lost in the time before we do? That’s not hope either that’s just reality. Gas laws, math, science and what happens. It will be undeniable then.
We were told we had more time, and we do. But everything that is vulnerable does not. That time is running out and the consequences will be immense. 70% of our globe is water and we worried about the smaller less than half the land we live on.
And yes I can back up everything I say with math, science and observation. If you want to see a dissolved reef look up carysfort reef. That’s one that was documented to dissolve as of 2016, that was a decade ago.
https://news.agu.org/press-release/ocean-acidification-may-be-impacting-coral-reefs-in-the-florida-keys/@SlicerDicer thanks! I will reply to your messages later… currently using my iPhone. Will be easier with a keyboard @feld @brianvastag
-
@andycarolan @feld @brianvastag Tipping points don’t exactly explain. Not really.
See carbonate is not just reefs. Reefs are what is most visible. Say where my wife is from on Whidbey? The oysters dissolve in their larval stage. Richard Feely did that work. Crabs? They can do the same. Krill? Sure. They dissolve too. Plankton all of that.
So you wonder why whales are starving? This pressure is hitting them. Colder water? More acid. There’s that too. We have altered the ccd the carbonate compensation depth. Our own blood acid is increasing from this.
Secondary to that heat is the enemy right? Well the dissolution hits in winter as cold water obviously holds more gas. This is why warm water goes hypoxic is it holds less gas. So cool the water down and it has higher co2 levels. This does not bode well for geoengineering. If you look at the effect we lower the global temperature we then lower the ocean temp. That creates more dissolution time.
It’s very bad actually and that’s why I say all of this is foregone conclusion. The problem is the time it would take to resolve things vs how long till things get really bad. The invisible problems are what make it complicated.
As to individual level? Don’t feel responsible. It’s not like any one thing you can do. That’s really the truth. It requires a mindset shift across the planet or it’s not worth doing. We worried too much about storms, sea level rise and heat. We did not worry about the real things that would arrive, we discussed 2100 we did not discuss the 2030-2040 problem.
I know all of this too well. I watched the 3rd largest barrier reef go from a beautiful place and incredible life in my childhood 30 years ago turn to a graveyard today. What’s another 30 years going to do? It’s estimated to fix the septic systems would take 30 years. We just don’t have time to deal with it.
These photos below are what the environment looks like in the keys that was once a healthy reef. One that I spent time at as a child as I lived right by it.
In 1995 when my mom’s business was shut down by the Feds. Her live rock collection business was supposed to be the actual change. We decided to take things seriously with damage. The only problem was that in doing that it forced me to leave the keys. My mom could not maintain gainful employment after that. When that happened it went to a tourist land and fishing became the thing. Instead of fixing everything that would have cost an immense amount of money? We chose to do token work. 174 people had their businesses shut down. Good enough, ignore the rest. That was 1995. I’m a living part of this catastrophe. To the point both my name and my mom’s name are immortalized at the UN for marine science. That’s how long this spans. Her for live rock and tropical fish collection and then me for the catastrophic damage of spinning fish. Spanning boomer to millennial, it’s quite a long time.
This is a life long thing for me. My entire life has been shaped by all this and why I am water. I was born into it and part of it.
As to banning plastic straws, that’s as we chose to outrage on the visible turtles. We protected the turtles but not the food they eat. We didn’t protect their predators that keep their population healthy. Thats the danger had we looked at the full symbiotic ecosystem it would have lead to major sweeping changes not just ohh one species here and there. Plastic is a problem, but far more important is how many straws actually end up in ocean?@SlicerDicer While I find it difficult to understand much of the science, I do appreciate that the ocean is a complex, interwoven system that humans have caused great damage to
- If one thing is impacted, it appears to cause a cascade of effects. I think, as with a lot of things, humans look at one headline symptom, and no further. Like the plastic straws. Am I correct in thinking that much of the microplastics in the oceans is due to fishing nets? Straws again felt like a carefully marketed tactic to do something which was only a small part of a much bigger problem.
@feld @brianvastag -
@SlicerDicer While I find it difficult to understand much of the science, I do appreciate that the ocean is a complex, interwoven system that humans have caused great damage to
- If one thing is impacted, it appears to cause a cascade of effects. I think, as with a lot of things, humans look at one headline symptom, and no further. Like the plastic straws. Am I correct in thinking that much of the microplastics in the oceans is due to fishing nets? Straws again felt like a carefully marketed tactic to do something which was only a small part of a much bigger problem.
@feld @brianvastag@andycarolan @feld @brianvastag I mean I don’t even really care about fishing nets or plastic or any of that. of the ocean. That’s not gonna be easily solved.
Plastic is only notable as it’s part of our lives. We see it we deal with it we know it. Invisible forces that cause acid and dissolution and disease are different entirely.
Resolve the algae blooms, stop feeding the lawns down there. Turn it back to low nutrient environments like a reef is supposed to be. Do the same for the rest of the water. That will buy us the most time, getting rid of nitrogen.
https://youtu.be/tegBETX6MLw?is=OHRXXQD_wX0RSaEY
Watch this video. -
@andycarolan @feld @brianvastag >> Those are amazing pictures! Looks gorgeous! I wasn’t aware what coral bleaching was, so just did a search. Another effect of climate change I see. Ugh
Why is this not bigger news?!
Well you know the bleaching news is getting less and less these days. After 2023 there’s not much left to bleach. Below is a porite coral that mustard hill. It’s one of the strongest corals out there for heat and water quality toasted in 2023. More terrifying is the upside down jellyfish in 2023 bleached in the other picture. That photos and videos I got of them was the first time wild bleaching was observed. The species that we studied for their zooz to try to solve the problem. They bleach at far higher temperatures so it was once thought we could use them. To transplant their zooz to the coral and give them more time. Well the wild bleaching of this species shows that even they are not immune. That the frontier hope of restoring coral was just obliterated by the effects outrunning the species.
These things are very real and happening. Coral, anemones, flatworms, Halimeda, sponges, jellyfish all bleached. Moon jellies turned black. Never in my life had I seen that scale of damage. 2023 was really the fork in the road.
So with bigger news? Well there’s not really any news since it went from 80% coral cover in 1995 to 0.5% in 2023 though many warm and cold bleaching events. what are you really going to show? It’s already happened. With really minimal observation by science. We should have had weekly if not bi weekly data for every single reef if we took it seriously and be able to look that up and see what’s happened.
So not really much to show there. That’s where we are at. It’s not like I’m trying to be scary either it’s just what it is. I’m not unaware either of what economic damage would result from deciding to fix this. What we would have to do as a species. That’s a non starter to put the globe in an instant depression to resolve it is not viable. That resolves nothing as we would lose the ability to make it work. So not like I’m saying we need to do immediate policy change. That won’t help anything to force massive change to resolve it.
It just is what it is, not that I’ve given up by any means. Just physics and chemistry doesn’t care about what we feel. Just the same as it doesn’t care if I do decompression properly it will gladly let me do it. It will let me damage my body, paralyze myself or kill myself. With zero complaints. Physics does not care of what we want. We are subject to its rules and its consequences. With that, I haven’t given up but I’ve just accepted what the laws of the universe dictate will happen. Gas saturation laws, thermodynamics, chemistry with gas interacting. Those are invisible forces that we cannot escape.
It’s gonna be rough in the future, post 2034 is my cutoff date when it really starts to become noticeable. In few short years we will see it switch. That’s when we will take real action. But what will we have lost in the time before we do? That’s not hope either that’s just reality. Gas laws, math, science and what happens. It will be undeniable then.
We were told we had more time, and we do. But everything that is vulnerable does not. That time is running out and the consequences will be immense. 70% of our globe is water and we worried about the smaller less than half the land we live on.
And yes I can back up everything I say with math, science and observation. If you want to see a dissolved reef look up carysfort reef. That’s one that was documented to dissolve as of 2016, that was a decade ago.
https://news.agu.org/press-release/ocean-acidification-may-be-impacting-coral-reefs-in-the-florida-keys/@SlicerDicer “80% coral cover in 1995 to 0.5% in 2023” That’s a terrifying rate of destruction! There must be whole dead zones throughout now!
While my replies may be short, I am grateful that you have taken the time to explain this… I just wish there was more I could do
@feld @brianvastag -
@andycarolan @brianvastag
> I didn’t realise that sucralose is a forever chemical.
I only learned about this from @SlicerDicer who shared this knowledge as scientists now find it in every water sample they analyze. I think some of his marine biologist peers have spoken to him about it.@feld jfc this stuff just never ceases @andycarolan @brianvastag @SlicerDicer
-
@SlicerDicer “80% coral cover in 1995 to 0.5% in 2023” That’s a terrifying rate of destruction! There must be whole dead zones throughout now!
While my replies may be short, I am grateful that you have taken the time to explain this… I just wish there was more I could do
@feld @brianvastag@andycarolan @feld @brianvastag
Well as to dead? I mean like fuck me. I’ve long wished I could Vulcan mind meld then be like look at this. That I have seen and now let’s go look at it. Tell me on what level is that ok.
So what does it look like down there? I don’t recognize it. This video I shot at newfound harbor a noaa iconic reef. Well where’s the coral? It was insane when I was a kid there with Staghorn, elk horn and brain corals, mountain star corals. Like it’s all gone. All that remains is the carbonate skeletons.
Just shit absolute shit. Why would I dive that then if it’s so shitty? Well just because it’s dead does not mean I don’t like diving. -
@andycarolan @feld @brianvastag
Well as to dead? I mean like fuck me. I’ve long wished I could Vulcan mind meld then be like look at this. That I have seen and now let’s go look at it. Tell me on what level is that ok.
So what does it look like down there? I don’t recognize it. This video I shot at newfound harbor a noaa iconic reef. Well where’s the coral? It was insane when I was a kid there with Staghorn, elk horn and brain corals, mountain star corals. Like it’s all gone. All that remains is the carbonate skeletons.
Just shit absolute shit. Why would I dive that then if it’s so shitty? Well just because it’s dead does not mean I don’t like diving.@SlicerDicer what an absolute tragedy to behold
-
@feld jfc this stuff just never ceases @andycarolan @brianvastag @SlicerDicer
@dch @feld @andycarolan @brianvastag Right? The fact the below existed some of them have been shut but not all. Imagine giant shit pipe blasting that water. Like we just discharge like hell too. There is massive problems.
Miami decided to just pump it down underground. Injection always worked out well just look at Hawaii.
https://www.palmbeachpost.com/story/news/2010/11/01/broward-balks-at-order-to/7443957007/
Broward County wants to escape a state mandate to shut down a pipe that discharges treated sewage into the ocean off Pompano Beach, saying the cost would be huge and the environmental payoff negligible.
https://www.mauicounty.gov/m/faq?cat=83
Yes. There are numerous privately-owned and operated injection wells in our county. Many privately-owned condominiums and businesses in areas that were built outside of existing County of Maui sewer service have their own injection well(s). Single-family homes built outside sewer service areas use cesspools or septic systems discharging minimally treated waste directly into the ground.
https://www.tampa.gov/wastewater/info/advanced-wastewater-treatment-plant
Tampa did this that removes most of the nitrogen.
https://www.fkaa.com/260/Cudjoe-Regional-Wastewater
Cudjoe key did it too. AWT is the best thing we can do at scale and it is possible.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login