why are Nature mag and John Hopkins Bioethics @bermaninstitute calling LLM stochastic parrots “doctors”?
-
RE: https://mastodon.world/@bermaninstitute/117490867842398359
why are Nature mag and John Hopkins Bioethics @bermaninstitute calling LLM stochastic parrots “doctors”?
-
T #medicine shared this topic on
-
RE: https://mastodon.world/@bermaninstitute/117490867842398359
why are Nature mag and John Hopkins Bioethics @bermaninstitute calling LLM stochastic parrots “doctors”?
@blogdiva @bermaninstitute oh fucking GROSS
Not a good sign that they've picked up the language used by fascists and eugenicists.
"AI doctors" are just eugenics and a way to let "the poors" die. It's not high quality healthcare, it's not low quality healthcare: it's *not even healthcare*. It's saying "WebMD is good enough for you, now die." -
RE: https://mastodon.world/@bermaninstitute/117490867842398359
why are Nature mag and John Hopkins Bioethics @bermaninstitute calling LLM stochastic parrots “doctors”?
This whole thing is very funny, in the sense that the tests, referrals, and medications the LLM is "suggesting" are probably *exactly what the doctors should be ordering according to their own best practices AS WRITTEN DOWN* but have been trained not to by insurance companies and neofascists.
I guarantee you that rich people who pay cash for healthcare get the same recos from their cash-only doctors.
-
This whole thing is very funny, in the sense that the tests, referrals, and medications the LLM is "suggesting" are probably *exactly what the doctors should be ordering according to their own best practices AS WRITTEN DOWN* but have been trained not to by insurance companies and neofascists.
I guarantee you that rich people who pay cash for healthcare get the same recos from their cash-only doctors.
They talk about it "driving up the cost of care" as though the LLMs are somehow increasing the price of the services. But what they actually mean is "nobody can afford to do all this great healthcare for the poors!"
We live in a hellscape in which "finding out what's actually wrong" is "driving up the cost of care" so they just stamp "idiopathic" on a sheet of paper and send you home with some aspirin.
-
They talk about it "driving up the cost of care" as though the LLMs are somehow increasing the price of the services. But what they actually mean is "nobody can afford to do all this great healthcare for the poors!"
We live in a hellscape in which "finding out what's actually wrong" is "driving up the cost of care" so they just stamp "idiopathic" on a sheet of paper and send you home with some aspirin.
Using LLMs in healthcare is fucking insane, period. Everyone who uses an LLM in a healthcare setting should have their license revoked and should be sued into the ground.
But one thing about LLMs that's really quite satisfying is when the corrupt humans, who have long strayed from the written-down best practices of their discipline, are confronted with LLMs who are stochastically parroting back...those best practices.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login